When will transgender women deliver babies?
by Michael Cook | 18 Jun 2016 | 6 comments
from Scientific American / Getty Images
If we welcome transgender women, are transgender mothers a big deal? Although surgeons are still mastering the technique of transplanting wombs, patients are already asking when this will become possible.At the moment, the only team which has succeeded in transplanting a uterus into a woman who later gave birth is in Sweden. Dr Mats Brännström developed the operation to help women who had been born without a uterus or who had to have hysterectomies. But elsewhere in Europe and in the US doctors are attempting the daunting surgery and it has been widely publicized. Scientific American spoke to several doctors who said that a handful of their transwomen patients were interested, even though it is still far from successful.
“A lot of this work [in women] is intended to go down that road but no one is talking about that,” Mark Sauer, a professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Columbia University, told the magazine. .
The operation is far more complex than most people imagine. First, the aspiring transwoman needs to create IVF embryos and store them. Then there is castration surgery and high doses of hormones. Surgery would be needed to create a “neo-vagina”. Anti-rejection drugs are needed.
There are other issues as well: the cost is very high and the operation could last for 10 or 11 hours. Would it be ethical for a doctor to allow a patient to risk his life in experimental surgery when there are safer alternatives for having children like adoption?
The one bright side is that uteruses will be available, since people who transition from female to male may have their wombs removed. Some have already asked doctors whether they could donate them.
The bottom line, say most doctors, is that men won’t be having babies any time soon. “I respect reproduction and I don’t think we will ever see this in my lifetime in a transgender woman,” says Marci Bowers, a gynecological surgeon in California. “That’s what I tell my patients.”
I have no love for Donald Trump, but it does seem unfair that only he is being accused of being crazy in this year’s election for president. It is a truth universally acknowledged that any man (or woman) who hankers after high public office must be in need of a psychiatrist. In 2013 psychologists published an article asserting that most recent presidents have suffered from “grandiose narcissism, which comprises immodesty, boastfulness and interpersonal dominance”. Remember that Hillary Clinton has been accused of all these failings, not just Trump. Perhaps they are crafty, not crazy.
That’s why the Goldwater Rule is a good thing. As Xavier Symons mentions below, this is an informal rule of medical ethics for psychologists and psychiatrists which bans them from commenting on the mental state and stability of public figures. It’s very rash to predict that psychological flaws disqualify a person from holding public office. Winston Churchill was depressive and an alcoholic and became the most admired statesman of the 20th century. Abraham Lincoln probably suffered from depression but is the most revered of all American presidents. Mr Trump may be unsuited to the job of president, but I’d prefer to make up my own mind on the subject without airy speculation from psychiatrists who have never spoken to the man himself.
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
This week in BioEdge | |
by Xavier Symons | Jun 18, 2016
Professional associations ban comments on public figuresby Xavier Symons | Jun 18, 2016
Can a child ask for withdrawal of treatment?by Michael Cook | Jun 18, 2016
The short answer is: don't hold your breathby Xavier Symons | Jun 18, 2016
The American Medical Association has labelled gun violence a “public health crisis” and called on congress to fund research into gun related crime.by Michael Cook | Jun 18, 2016
Ethicists have serious doubts about the procedure, even in Chinaby Michael Cook | Jun 18, 2016
But donation goes against strong cultural prejudicesby Michael Cook | Jun 18, 2016
"They become an unacceptable economic burden in time of crisis"by Michael Cook | Jun 18, 2016
A pioneer in modern medical ethics broke some of the rulesby Michael Cook | Jun 18, 2016
Is a knighthood part of a publicity campaign for three-parent embryos?BioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org
New Media Foundation | Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario