Volume 22, Number 4—April 2016
Ritual Slaughter as Overlooked Risk Factor for Brucellosis
To the Editor: The current rates of animal and human brucellosis in southern Israel are unacceptably high (1). Unsupervised livestock rearing, smuggling of herds, and the dissolution of Israel’s “test, slaughter, and compensate” program for small ruminants in 1997 have generated a large, uncontrolled animal reservoir in the region. The Bedouin Arab inhabitants who live in close proximity to herds and consume unpasteurized dairy products are disproportionately affected. Outbreaks from parts of Israel that were previously free of brucellosis are reported with increasing frequency. Moreover, 2 decades after supposed elimination of bovine brucellosis, a cattle herd adjacent to Bedouin grazing areas was found to be highly infected with Brucella melitensis (2).
We report 5 cases of severe brucellosis in patients from a community whose members typically do not raise herds and do not consume unpasteurized dairy products. The patients were Ethiopian-born Jews who exhibited fever and either respiratory signs or radiologic evidence of new pulmonary findings (Table). The true nature of the infection only became evident when B. melitensis was identified from blood cultures. Directed questioning revealed that all patients participated in ceremonial slaughter of sheep that were purchased from Bedouin owners in southern Israel.
The diagnostic pitfalls encountered by the medical staff are exemplified in the case of patient 1 (Table). In May 2014, this 68-year-old man was admitted to a hospital in southern Israel, with a 14-day history of fever, cough, and night sweats. His medical history was notable for asthma and previously treated pulmonary tuberculosis (TB). Computed tomography scan of his chest showed a new 1.5-cm2 apical lung lesion with irregular borders. Laboratory evaluations were negative for rickettsiae, Coxiella burnetii, HIV, Plasmodium spp., andMycobacterium tuberculosis. Four days after admission, gram-negative coccobacilli grew from his blood culture.Brucella IgM titer was 1:1,920. The patient received appropriate treatment for 6 weeks (Table) and recovered.Brucella IgM titers dropped to 1:40. Four months later, he returned to the infectious diseases clinic exhibiting fever, chills, and clinical and sonographic evidence of epididymo-orchitis. Brucella IgM titers rose to 1:1,240. Treatment was resumed for 3 months. In addition, a thoracoscopic biopsy of the lung lesion was performed to rule out malignancy. Pathologic examination of the biopsy specimen revealed a focus of fibrosis, with giant cells surrounded by lymphocytes (Technical Appendix[PDF - 285 KB - 2 pages] Figure). After treatment, the patient’s symptoms resolved and titers returned to low levels.
The long symptom-to-diagnosis interval (range 21–97 days) for patients in this report is alarming (Table). Treatment delays are associated with increased focal complications and relapse rates (3). Further, high case-fatality rates, allegedly due to low physician awareness, were reported in a largely immigrant cohort of brucellosis patients in Germany (4).
Several circumstances might have led to the failure to include brucellosis in the initial differential diagnosis for these patients, even in a disease-endemic region. First, we can assume that physicians are unfamiliar with the ceremonial slaughter central to the celebrations of Ethiopian Jews. The tradition includes slaughtering, skinning, and eviscerating a sheep, followed by mincing of the sheep meat. This venerated ritual is performed by trained members of the Ethiopian community and supervised by the spiritual leader, the Kes (5). Second, patients were consistently reluctant to disclose their participation in ceremonial slaughter to medical staff. Third, the managing physicians considered differential diagnoses for febrile respiratory illness in line with the patients’ Ethiopian origins: reactivation of TB or chronic pulmonary disease exacerbation (6). Patients 3 and 5 had a history of prolonged cough at admission; patient 3 had chest radiograph results suggestive of miliary TB. Finally, for patient 5, Actinobacillus ureae was initially but erroneously identified as the cause of bacteremia.
All patients in our study had clinical or radiologic evidence of lung involvement. Causality between exposure to Brucella-infected aerosols and pulmonary manifestations of brucellosis has been demonstrated in animal models. After an aerosol challenge with B. melitensis, animal lungs have shown perivascular inflammation as well as microgranulomas (7). In a study of hunters infected with B. suis, in which 38% had respiratory symptoms, aerosol spread or conjuctival innoculation was considered the most likely route of infection (3).
Aerosol exposure during slaughter could be linked to the pulmonary manifestations of brucellosis observed in these patients. The granulomatous changes in the lung biopsy specimens of patient 1 are typical of lung involvement in brucellosis (8). The patients in this report did not use protective gear during contact with animal parts, which inevitably increased their risk for infection through direct or aerosol contact (9).
This reports illustrates an unsuspected mode of brucellosis transmission in an area with soaring brucellosis rates: transmission from infected animals to persons clandestinely engaging in ritual slaughter; specifically, an Ethiopian Jewish community. Physicians in countries receiving immigrants should be aware of ceremonial practices that place patients at risk for zoonoses. The severe respiratory manifestations that ensued following aerosol exposure to animal blood or secretions suggest that brucellosis with pulmonary involvement after inhalation of Brucella-infected aerosols might be more common than previously documented.
- Shemesh A, Yagupsky P. Increasing incidence of human brucellosis in southern Israel after the cessation of a veterinarian control campaign. Air Water Borne Diseases. 2013;2:112. http://www.omicsgroup.org/journals/increasing-incidence-of-human-brucellosis-in-southern-israel-after-the-cessation-of-a-veterinarian-control-campaign-2167-7719.1000112.php?aid=17444
- Brucellosis—Israel. (02): (Hadarom) melitensis, bovine, human. ProMED-mail. 2015 31 Oct [cited 2015 Oct 31]. http://www.promedmail.org, archive no. 20151031.3757610.
- Eales KM, Norton RE, Ketheesan N. Short report: brucellosis in northern Australia. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2010;83:876–8 .
- Al Dahouk S, Neubauer H, Hensel A, Sconeberg I, Nockler K, Alpers K, Changing epidemiology of human brucellosis, Germany 1962–2005. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007;13:1895–900.
- Salomon H. Blood between the Beta Israel and their Christian neighbours in Ethiopia—key symbols in an inter-group context [article in Hebrew]. Jerusalem Studies in Jewish Folklore. Mandel Institute for Jewish Studies. 1993 [cited 2015 Jan 6]. http://www.jstor.org/stable/23356293
- Rosenberg R, Vinker S, Zakut H, Kizner F, Nakar S, Kitai E. An unusually high prevalence of asthma in Ethiopian immigrants to Israel. Fam Med.1999;31:276–9 .
- Henning LN, Miller SM, Pak DH, Lindsay A, Fisher DA, Barnewall R, Pathophysiology of the rhesus macaque model for inhalational brucellosis. Infect Immun. 2012;80:298–310.
- Theegarten D, Albrecht S, Totsch M, Teschler H, Neubauer H, Al Dahouk S. Brucellosis of the lung: case report and review of the literature. Virchows Arch. 2008;452:97–101.
- Nabukenya I, Kaddu-Mulindwa D, Nasinyama G. Survey of Brucella infection and malaria among abattoir workers in Kampala and Mbarara districts, Uganda. BMC Public Health. 2013;13:901.
Suggested citation for this article: Fuchs I, Osyntsov L, Refaely Y, Ciobotaro P, Zimhony O. Ritual slaughter as overlooked risk factor for brucellosis [letter]. Emerg Infect Dis. 2016 [date cited]. http://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid2204.151192
"Et al" found after fewer than 6 authors. Please check reference (in reference 7 "Henning, Miller, Pak, Lindsay, Fisher, et al., 2012").
Reference has only first page number. Please provide the last page number if article is longer than one page. (in reference 9 "Nabukenya, Kaddu-Mulindwa, Nasinyama, 2013").