lunes, 28 de noviembre de 2016

Ahead of Print -Molecular, Spatial, and Field Epidemiology Suggesting TB Transmission in Community, Not Hospital, Gaborone, Botswana - Volume 23, Number 3—March 2017 - Emerging Infectious Disease journal - CDC

Ahead of Print -Molecular, Spatial, and Field Epidemiology Suggesting TB Transmission in Community, Not Hospital, Gaborone, Botswana - Volume 23, Number 3—March 2017 - Emerging Infectious Disease journal - CDC

Volume 23, Number 3—March 2017


Molecular, Spatial, and Field Epidemiology Suggesting TB Transmission in Community, Not Hospital, Gaborone, Botswana



Technical Appendices


Diya SurieComments to Author , Othusitse Fane, Alyssa Finlay, Matsiri Ogopotse, James L. Tobias, Eleanor S. Click, Chawangwa Modongo, Nicola M. Zetola, Patrick K. Moonan, John E. Oeltmann, and for the Kopanyo Study Group
Author affiliations: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA (D. Surie, A. Finlay, E.S. Click, P.K. Moonan, J.E. Oeltmann)Botswana-UPenn Partnership, Gaborone, Botswana (O. Fane, M. Ogopotse, C. Modongo, N.M. Zetola)Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Gaborone (A. Finlay)Northrop Grumman, Atlanta, (J.L. Tobias)


During 2012–2015, 10 of 24 patients infected with matching genotypes of Mycobacterium tuberculosisreceived care at the same hospital in Gaborone, Botswana. Nosocomial transmission was initially suspected, but we discovered plausible sites of community transmission for 20 (95%) of 21 interviewed patients. Active case-finding at these sites could halt ongoing transmission.
Tuberculosis (TB) results from rapid progression of a recently acquired Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection or from reactivation of a remote infection (1). It is critical that recent M. tuberculosis infections be identified because TB is more likely to develop in persons with recent infections (2). Furthermore, the finding of recently infected persons suggests ongoing transmission of TB, which can be interrupted by prompt identification and treatment of undiagnosed cases (3). However, finding undiagnosed cases remains a challenge (4). Name-based contact investigations have traditionally been used for this purpose, but such investigations are resource-intensive (5), making them less practical in countries to which TB is endemic. Genotyping of M. tuberculosis has emerged as a complementary method to detect ongoing transmission because persons who have the same TB genotype may be involved in the same chain of transmission (6). Although this assumption is relatively reliable in low-incidence countries, it is yet to be determined whether genotyping in TB-endemic settings can similarly detect ongoing transmission.
We investigated a TB cluster of 24 patients with matching M. tuberculosis genotypes in Gaborone, Botswana, a city with a high number of TB cases (7). Because almost half of these patients received care at the same hospital, nosocomial transmission was suspected. We conducted an investigation to determine if TB transmission occurred among these patients within the hospital and to identify possible alternate sites of ongoing transmission of this TB strain.
The Study
During August 2012–January 2015, all consenting persons with TB at 26 facilities in Gaborone provided sputum samples for culture as part of the Kopanyo study (8). M. tuberculosis isolates were genotyped by 24-locus mycobacterial interspersed repetitive units–variable number tandem repeats (9).
We assessed nosocomial transmission by reviewing dates of hospital visits for overlap among the 24 TB cluster-associated patients. The hospital’s electronic billing system was used to obtain all previous dates of admission, discharge, and visits to the accidents and emergency department that had occurred for these patients since 2004.
We interviewed each patient, using an investigation form (Technical Appendix[PDF - 237 KB - 2 pages]), to learn their primary residence; contacts; places of work and worship; and other frequented locations, including bars and combi (minibus) routes used in the 6 months before diagnosis. Primary residences of patients were mapped by using global positioning system coordinates (8). Ethical approval was obtained from the University of Pennsylvania, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Botswana Ministry of Health, and University of Botswana.
We looked for epidemiologic links that might suggest ongoing transmission. An epidemiologic link was defined for patients having at least 1 of the following associations: overlapping visits at the hospital, living within 1 km of another cluster-associated patient (spatial link), frequenting the same locations as another cluster-associated patient, and naming another cluster-associated patient as a contact.
During the study, ≈60% of M. tuberculosis isolates from reported TB patients in Gaborone were genotyped. The cluster discussed in this report includes 24 (2.3%) of 1,033 total genotyped cases from Gaborone.
Thumbnail of Timing of hospital visits and treatment for 10 tuberculosis cluster–associated patients, Gaborone, Botswana, 2013–2015. Patients were hospitalized or seen in the accident and emergency ward, and all had a history of such visits since 2004. Visits prior to October 2013 are not shown; these include visits in 2012 by patients A and I and additional visits by patients N, T, and U. None of the pre-October 2013 visits overlapped with those of other tuberculosis cluster–associated patients
Figure 1. Timing of hospital visits and treatment for 10 tuberculosis cluster–associated patients, Gaborone, Botswana, 2013–2015. Patients were hospitalized or seen in the accident and emergency ward, and all had a history of...
All patients had pulmonary disease involvement (Table 1). Ten (42%) had received care at the hospital since 2004; most visits occurred after October 2013 (Figure 1). Except for visits by 2 patients, no patients’ visits overlapped at the hospital. Patients V and X overlapped in the hospital for 3 days, albeit in separate buildings. Patient V was admitted to the hospital with a known diagnosis of TB and had started TB therapy the day before admission. Patient X was in the hospital for a week but did not start TB therapy until 13 days after patient V was admitted. No members of this cluster were healthcare workers.
Thumbnail of Residence-associated data for patients in a tuberculosis cluster, Gaborone, Botswana, 2012–2015. A) Primary residences of 20 patients are indicated by red dots. Inset map shows location of Gaborone in Botswana. Black lines demarcate neighborhoods; gray lines demarcate property parcels; pink circles represent 0.5-km radius around a patient’s residence; and red rectangles indicate presence of 14 patients in 4 distinct neighborhoods, 13 of whom had spatial links. Four patients who are
Figure 2. Residence-associated data for patients in a tuberculosis cluster, Gaborone, Botswana, 2012–2015. A) Primary residences of 20 patients are indicated by red dots. Inset map shows location of Gaborone in Botswana. Black...
Twenty (83%) patients had a primary residence in Gaborone; 14 resided in 4 distinct neighborhoods (Figure 2, panel A). The spatial link definition (residing < 1 km from another cluster-associated patient) was met by 13 (54%) patients. One patient (B) lived slightly > 1 km from the nearest patient (Figure 2, panel B). Two of 4 spatially linked patients (C, D, I, and W) (Figure 2, panel B) did not name each other during enrollment when asked about contacts; when interviewed again as part of this investigation, these patients confirmed spending time together around the time of their diagnosis.
One patient died and 2 were lost to follow-up. Thus, 21 patients contributed to the remaining epidemiologic links obtained from interviews (Table 2). The median number of specific locations reported by patients was 6 (range 1–13). Of the 21 patients, 11 (52%) reported attending the same bar as another patient; 1 of these patients worked as a bartender. Site visits to 2 of the bars revealed an environment conducive to TB transmission (closed, poorly ventilated space crowded with patrons and employees). Similar crowded conditions were observed in combis, and 16 (76%) patients reported using the same combi route as another patient. Eight (38%) patients attended the same church as another patient, and 6 (29%) patients named each other as a contact, suggesting transmission could have occurred among them.


TB genotyping surveillance prompted a targeted investigation, which, when combined with spatial and field epidemiologic data, identified unsuspected locations of possible transmission. TB transmission from 1 cluster-associated patient to another at the hospital seemed unlikely. Although 2 patients’ hospital stays overlapped by 3 days, nosocomial transmission between them probably did not occur because the patients were hospitalized in separate buildings and the time from TB exposure and treatment initiation (13 days) is an extremely short time for disease to develop (10). Instead, the combination of links among patients suggests ongoing community transmission. Plausible sites of transmission included specific neighborhoods, bars, combi routes, and churches, transmission locations consistent with reports from other TB-endemic settings (11,12). These findings demonstrate the critical role that nonhousehold-based TB transmission plays in sub-Saharan Africa and highlight the need for identifying community-based TB transmission. A multidisciplinary approach (i.e., use of genotyping, spatial analyses, and interviews) provided us with locations where additional persons may be at risk for TB.
Our study has limitations. First, because samples from every TB case in Gaborone were not genotyped and interviews were not conducted with all persons in this cluster, key linkages between patients may have been missed. Second, underreporting of locations might have occurred due to patients’ inability to remember all locations visited; thus, some less frequented places where transmission might have occurred may have been missed. Third, we could not prove that patients who attended the same location interacted with each other at that location while infectious. Fourth, if a cluster-associated patient went to the hospital as a visitor, not a patient, their overlap with another cluster-associated patient could have been missed. Fifth, the extent to which the hospital infection-control program influenced our findings is unknown. Sixth, because 24-locus mycobacterial interspersed repetitive units–variable number tandem repeats characterizes only a portion of the M. tuberculosis genome, it is possible for 2 different strains to appear similar. Whole-genome sequencing could help confirm (or refute) the findings in this investigation.
Although genotyping is an imperfect tool for confirming transmission between patients, we know that numerous patients in this cluster visited the same community locations while they were potentially infectious, which alone could justify further active case-finding at these locations. With an estimated incidence of 385 TB cases/100,000 persons in Botswana (7), such clues are needed to focus TB control efforts. Active case-finding targeted at the most frequently visited community locations could help stop ongoing transmission of this strain.
Dr. Surie is an Epidemic Intelligence Service officer in the Division of Global HIV and TB, Center for Global Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in Atlanta, Georgia. Her primary research interests are molecular epidemiology and tuberculosis and HIV co-infection.


We are grateful to the TB patients and their families for participating in this study. We thank the district health team and recruitment and retention officers who helped us coordinate with and contact patients. We are indebted to the Botswana National Tuberculosis Program and Botswana Ministry of Health for their partnership in this effort. We also thank the following persons for their thoughtful reviews of this manuscript: Benjamin Silk, Thomas Navin, Laura Podewils, Colleen Scott, and Carla Winston.
This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health (grant R01AI097045; principal investigator: N.M.Z.) and the United States President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief.
Members of the Kopanyo Study Group: Joyce Basotli, Ebi Bile, Rosanna Boyd, Victoria Cowger, Mbatshi Dima, Sambayawo Gwebe-Nyirenda, Cynthia Caiphus, Thandi Katlholo, Christopher Serumola, Tsaone Tamuhla, Goitseone Thamae, Onani Zimba, Pilara Khumongwana, Kitso Ramogale, Sanghuk Shin, James Shepherd.


  1. Frieden TRSterling TRMunsiff SSWatt CJDye CTuberculosis. Lancet2003;362:88799DOIPubMed
  2. Horsburgh CR JrPriorities for the treatment of latent tuberculosis infection in the United States. N Engl J Med2004;350:20607DOIPubMed
  3. Yuen CMAmanullah FDharmadhikari ANardell EASeddon JAVasilyeva Iet al. Turning off the tap: stopping tuberculosis transmission through active case-finding and prompt effective treatment. Lancet2015;386:233443DOIPubMed
  4. Stop TB. Partnership. The Global Plan to End TB 2016–2020 [cited 2016 Jan 20].
  5. National Tuberculosis Controllers AssociationCenters for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)Guidelines for the investigation of contacts of persons with infectious tuberculosis. Recommendations from the National Tuberculosis Controllers Association and CDC. MMWR Recomm Rep2005;54(No. RR-15):147.PubMed
  6. Barnes PFCave MDMolecular epidemiology of tuberculosis. N Engl J Med2003;349:114956DOIPubMed
  7. World Health Organization. Global tuberculosis report 2015. Geneva: the Organization; 2015.
  8. Zetola NMModongo CMoonan PKClick EOeltmann JEShepherd Jet al. Tuberculosis and multidrug-resistant tuberculosis transmission dynamics among communities with high HIV prevalence: the Botswana Kopanyo Study. BMJ Open2016;6:e010046DOIPubMed
  9. Supply PAllix CLesjean SCardoso-Oelemann MRüsch-Gerdes SWillery Eet al. Proposal for standardization of optimized mycobacterial interspersed repetitive unit-variable-number tandem repeat typing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. J Clin Microbiol2006;44:4498510DOIPubMed
  10. Wallgren AThe time-table of tuberculosis. Tubercle1948;29:24551DOIPubMed
  11. Chamie GWandera BMarquez CKato-Maeda MKamya MRHavlir DVet al. Identifying locations of recent TB transmission in rural Uganda: a multidisciplinary approach. Trop Med Int Health2015;20:53745DOIPubMed
  12. Verver SWarren RMMunch ZRichardson Mvan der Spuy GDBorgdorff MWet al. Proportion of tuberculosis transmission that takes place in households in a high-incidence area. Lancet2004;363:2124DOIPubMed



Technical Appendix

Suggested citation for this article: Surie D, Fane O, Finlay A, Ogopotse M, Tobias JL, Click ES, et al. Molecular, spatial, and field epidemiology evidence of community-based tuberculosis transmission, Gaborone, Botswana, 2012–2015. Emerg Infect Dis. 2017 Mar [date cited].
DOI: 10.3201/eid2303.161183

1Other members of the Kopanyo Study Group are listed at the end of this article.

No hay comentarios:

Publicar un comentario en la entrada