Analysis of the clinical efficacy of tumor resection methods used in 20 patients with clavicular tumor

Yun Liu†,
Xian-Ying Huang†,
Wen-Yu Feng,
Xiao-Ting Luo,
Chang-Wu Wei,
Jian-Hong Liu,
Yin-Juan Lai,
Zeng-Ming Xiao,
Xiao ZhangEmail author and
Xin-Li ZhanEmail author View ORCID ID profile

†Contributed equally

World Journal of Surgical Oncology201917:106

https://doi.org/10.1186/s12957-019-1642-4

Received: 2 April 2019
Accepted: 3 June 2019
Published: 17 June 2019

Abstract

Background

To retrospectively analyze the tumor resection method used in 20 patients with clavicular tumors and evaluate its clinical efficacy.

Methods

A total of 9 patients with clavicular benign tumors underwent intracapsular resection, and 11 patients with clavicular malignant tumors underwent tumor resection from May 2012 to May 2017. Of the 11 patients, 5 underwent clavicular reconstruction using the plate-cement complex. Surgical efficacy was assessed using the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society, Constant-Murley, and American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons shoulder outcome scores preoperatively until 12 months postoperatively.

Results

The average duration of follow-up care was 33.7 (12–71) months. Of the 20 patients, 3 patients died, 3 survived with tumor recurrence or metastasis, and 14 survived with no tumor recurrence. Among the 5 patients who underwent resection of malignant clavicular tumors and reconstruction, 2 underwent a re-operation because of a loose screw and plate displacement. In the functional assessment of the shoulder joint, patients with benign and malignant clavicular tumors showed significantly higher scores postoperatively compared with preoperative scores. For malignant clavicular tumors, no significant improvement was observed when comparing the non-reconstruction and reconstruction groups.

Conclusions

Surgery is an optimal treatment for clavicular tumors. In patients with benign clavicular tumors, simple intracapsular resection can achieve a satisfactory prognosis. Reconstruction of a clavicular defect after resection of a clavicular malignant tumor is not recommended.