Hi there,
Good on the Washington Post! It certainly takes a principled stand in its editorial on stem cell research. Not even its potential for curing dread diseases is sufficient reason to cross a bright line, it argues. "The creation of human embryos specifically for research that will destroy them is unconscionable. The government has no business funding it."
Unfortunately, that was in 1994 (October 2). Almost exactly 20 years later, the Post took a very different line. An editorial this week argued: "As long as scientists do not cross ethical lines much farther from where they are now ... researchers should have the flexibility to go in whichever direction is scientifically useful."
As Emerson once said, "a foolish inconsistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." No one can blame the Post for recalibrating its positions with the years. But a 180-degree turn is a different matter.
The 1994 editorial warned of the "slippery slope". Anyone who denies that this lacks force as an argument should read both editorials carefully. Twenty years ago, the "deeply alarmed" Post said that creating embryos for experimentation was "flat wrong". Now it says that "Some ethical worries are reasonable, but they are not enough reason to hold back this research."
What is very discouraging in this comparison is not so much the change in the Post's position as its decline in moral sophistication. Back in 1994, it recognised that serious ethical issues were involved. The issue could not be decided simply by acquiescing to scientists' demands. Now its position is essentially that the only thing that matters is financial and scientific success. Is this really progress?
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
Editor
BioEdge
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
Although euthanasia is legal in the Netherlands, some Dutch pharmacists are refusing to supply the lethal drugs needed to carry it out.
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
A member of the Russian Duma (parliament) has called for commercial surrogacy to be banned.
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
The Iranian parliament is to consider banning vasectomies as a way of pushing up the country's below-replacement birth rate.
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
Three American bioethicists have criticised Belgium's new law permitting children with a terminal illness to choose euthanasia
by Xavier Symons | Apr 27, 2014
Attorney Steven Wise defends his quest to gain legal standing and justice for animals in the US.
by Xavier Symons | Apr 27, 2014
There has been a 5% surge in the prescription of opoids for pregnant women in the US
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
IVF is partly responsible for a million extra twins born in the US between 1981 and 2012
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
Bunions seem ethically uncomplicated, but the burgeoning field of aesthetic podiatry must eventually raise some questions about what constitutes medically necessary treatment.
by Michael Cook | Apr 27, 2014
Changes could be afoot in Swiss legislation after a doctor was acquitted this week of violating regulations for assisted suicide.
Michael Cook
Editor
Editor
Office address: 75 Archer Street | Chatswood NSW 2067 | Australia
Phone: 61+2 9007-1187
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org
.png)
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario